"Dark Gray had the most consistent temperature at 88°F"

Which BEST explains why this a weak evidence statement?

"Dark Gray had the most consistent temperature at 88°F"

Which BEST explains why this a weak evidence statement?

The evidence statement is extra information that doesn't help answer the question.

The evidence statement contains a claim.

The evidence statement is based on bad/incorrect data.

The evidence statement contains reasoning.

The evidence statement is untrue.